犹太人说的最多的,就是自己在二战期间被德国的纳粹党杀害了600万人口。The thing Jews talk about most is that 6 million of their people were killed by the German Nazi Party during World War II.
但我曾在微博里经过简单的论证,认为当时德国的纳粹不可能杀害这么多犹太人。However, I once presented a brief argument on Weibo suggesting that it would have been impossible for the Nazis in Germany at that time to kill so many Jews.
首先,当时德国根本没有那么多石油进行尸体的焚烧而处理600万具尸体。First of all, Germany simply did not have nearly enough oil at the time to cremate 6 million bodies.
其次,当时德国也不可能有那么多遍布德国境内外的焚尸炉,进行那么多具至少几百万尸体的焚烧。Second, it would have been impossible for Germany at that time to have had so many crematoria scattered throughout Germany and beyond to cremate at least several million bodies.
假设焚烧一具尸体的时间是20分钟,一小时一个焚烧炉就可以焚烧3具尸体。https://ytilauxes.blogspot.com/2017/08/2017861156.html Assuming it takes 20 minutes to burn one body, one incinerator can burn 3 bodies per hour.
一个焚烧场至少20个炉子,20个炉子1小时就可以焚烧60具尸体。An incineration facility has at least 20 furnaces, and those 20 furnaces can incinerate 60 bodies in one hour.
一天满打满算工作12小时,去掉准备工作2小时,实际焚烧10小时,一个焚烧场20个炉子就可以最多焚烧600具尸体。Working a full 12-hour day, minus 2 hours for preparation, leaves 10 hours of actual cremation. A crematorium with 20 furnaces can cremate up to 600 bodies.
600万人口,假如只在一个焚烧场焚烧,就需要焚烧1000天。With a population of 6 million, if all waste were incinerated at a single incineration plant, it would take 1,000 days to burn it all.
假设德国境内境外不止20个焚烧场,即便如此,600万具尸体,也需要50天才能烧完。Assuming there are more than 20 crematoriums in Germany and abroad, even then, it would take 50 days to cremate 6 million bodies.
以上是烧完600万具尸体所需要的焚烧炉的数据,即,一个有20个炉子每天烧10小时的焚烧场,至少需要20个这样规模的焚烧场,才能在近2个月的时间里,把600万具尸体烧完。The above figures represent the number of crematoriums needed to cremate 6 million bodies. In other words, a crematorium with 20 furnaces operating 10 hours a day would require at least 20 such facilities to cremate 6 million bodies in just under two months.
其次,烧掉600万具尸体,需要更多的人手。Second, burning 6 million bodies would require more manpower.
第一是把大活人押运到焚烧场。一辆卡车可以押运最多20多人,就算21人,平均每3个犹太人由一名纳粹军官负责押运,那么21个犹太人,就需要另外7名纳粹军官,再加上司机,副驾驶,一辆卡车可以载运21名犹太人,最多10名纳粹军官。First, transporting living people to the crematoria. A truck could transport up to 20 or more people; even if we assume 21, with an average of one Nazi officer responsible for every three Jews, transporting 21 Jews would require an additional seven Nazi officers. Adding the driver and the co-driver, a single truck could carry 21 Jews and a maximum of 10 Nazi officers.
把活人押运到刑场,再由纳粹军官把活的犹太人开枪杀掉,这时开枪的活动可由前面负责押运的纳粹军官来完成。Live prisoners were escorted to the execution site, where Nazi officers shot the living Jews; the act of firing the shots could be carried out by the Nazi officers who had been in charge of the escort.
这样算下来,押运20名犹太人需要10名纳粹军官,则完全押运600万犹太人需要300万纳粹军官。Based on this calculation, if it takes 10 Nazi officers to escort 20 Jews, then it would take 3 million Nazi officers to escort all 6 million Jews.
犹太人死后,1名犹太人又需要至少2名纳粹军官把他们运送至焚烧场。600万犹太人尸体就需要1200万纳粹军官。除了前面负责押运的纳粹军官,又另外需要900万军官。After a Jew died, it took at least two Nazi officers to transport the body to the crematorium. The bodies of 6 million Jews would have required 12 million Nazi officers. In addition to the Nazi officers responsible for escorting the prisoners, another 9 million officers would have been needed.
犹太人被烧掉以后,还需要至少1名纳粹军官处理犹太人骨灰。After the Jews were burned, at least one Nazi officer was required to handle their ashes.
二战的时候,德国上战场的军民人数是1700万左右,还没打仗仅仅烧尸体就需要那么多人,所以正确的结论就是,压根没有600万犹太人被杀死。During World War II, the number of German military personnel and civilians who went to the front lines was around 17 million. It took that many people just to cremate the bodies—even before the fighting began—so the correct conclusion is that 6 million Jews were never killed in the first place.